---
title: "Rulings"
canonical: "https://www.ellwoodevidence.com/page/rulings"
format: markdown
---
> Dynamic module: Search Highlight (live content)

# $structureName

This page is a place for our team to present Canadian rulings that we find interesting. We are not lawyers and we do not offer legal advise of any kind.

We simply find these rulings to have an impact on the kind of work that we do and perhaps they will be helpful to others.

## Screenshot Are Not Good Evidence

**Wang v Liu, 2023 BCSC 972 (CanLII)**

\[71\]      In the end, I conclude that I am unable to place reliance on the Disputed WeChat Screenshots since I cannot be assured they reflect conversations between the parties that actually took place. To be clear, I am not finding that Ms. Liu fabricated the messages, just that I cannot be assured of their reliability. As such I place no reliance on them.

## Delay

**R. v. Jordan, 2016 SCC 27 (CanLII), \[2016\] 1 SCR 631**

At the heart of this new framework is a presumptive ceiling beyond which delay — from the charge to the actual or anticipated end of trial — is presumed to be unreasonable, unless exceptional circumstances justify it. The presumptive ceiling is 18 months for cases tried in the provincial court, and 30 months for cases in the superior court (or cases tried in the provincial court after a preliminary inquiry). Delay attributable to or waived by the defence does not count towards the presumptive ceiling.

## Privacy of an IP Address

**R. v. Bykovets, 2024 SCC 6 (CanLII)**

\[14\]                        I would allow the appeal. There is a reasonable expectation of privacy in an IP address. A request by the state for an IP address constitutes a search.

## The Workings of Torrential Downpour in BitTorrent peer-to-peer file-sharing Investigations and Roundup Suite of Investigative Tools

\[41\] Torrential Downpour Receptor and Torrential Downpourwere developed by the University of Massachusetts (Amherst). UMass owns the copyright. It provides it free to law enforcement.

...

\[43\] Torrential Downpour Receptor engages in automated surveillance of the BitTorrent swarm...

## Is Non-Responsive Material Discovered in a Digital Search Grounds for a Further Investigation?

Court of Appeal says No.

## Children

- [Non-responsive materials grounds for further investigation](https://www.ellwoodevidence.com/page/non-responsive-materials-grounds-for-further-investigation.md)
